Q: Have you had a character that disappointed you? One that you fell in love with and then "broke up" with later on in either the series or a stand-alone book? Tell us about him or her.
This is a great question--and one I am really struggling to answer. My first thought is Scarlett from Gone with the Wind, but the more I thought about it the more I realized it was more that I wanted to like her but I never really did. I admired her determination to survive and to do what she had to in order to beat the odds. But the way she stole her sister's beau, the way she treated Rhett (who is one of my literary crushes), and even the way she pawed after a married man--oh it makes me angry and annoyed just to think about it.So then I thought about Bridget Jones from Bridget Jones's Diary. Initially, I thought she was a funny character, but as the story continued and particularly as it continued into the second book I started to really not like her at all. She comes off as stupid and incompetent on many occasions. Do people really see her as a modern day Elizabeth Bennet? Irk! And throughout Pride and Prejudice, I never doubt what Darcy sees in Elizabeth. But I question many, many times what Darcy sees in Bridget Jones!
But finally I settled on Al from Divergent. In the beginning, I really felt for Al. He made a very tough decision when he changed factions--that takes courage. He openly showed his vulnerability--which I also think takes courage. But as the story progressed and as Tris started to describe some of the changes in Al, I became more and more unsure of him, of his motives for changing factions, of his motives regarding Tris, of his motives in general. So I came to not like him very much at all by the end.
I heard SO many good things abt Divergent. Haven't read it yet though. I understand what you mean by suddenly being "unsure" abt a character's motives. Not good...not good at all.
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for stopping by Book that Thing. Happy Friday to you :-)
I'm following back via GFC and Linky
_yay_
FollowFriday_Feature
Thank you so much for the follow back. Divergent is WONDERFUL! My copy has been shared around my entire office. :)
DeleteDivergent is on my TBR list. I hate it when you begin to suspect a character you love about not being truly open and honest. It sucks.
ReplyDeleteNew GFC follower.
Vikki @ V's Book Life
Yes, characters that are not open and honest can be so hard to get behind! :)
DeleteAwww I love Bridget! But I only read the first book, not the second. In the movies she's awesome! I agree on Al though! Great answer :)
ReplyDeleteHere's my FF!
I really liked her the first time--but when I watch it a second time or more I was so not impressed anymore. But I accept I may be in the minority here. :)
DeleteHum... I wonder what Bridget did to disappoint you.
ReplyDeleteI'm an old gfc follower. :)
http://notjustnonsense.blogspot.com.br/2012/04/ff-feature-and-follow-20.html
I can't name specific examples--mainly because I have not watched the movie or read the book in a long time. I found myself looking away and cringing so many times though. :)
DeleteShanan
http://thebookaddictnet.blogspot.com/2012/04/follow-friday-18.html
Hi, first may I just say how lovely it was to find your post on my blogger dashboard, its nice to have you back. Secondly, the question got me thinking... I'm sure there are a couple of characters that have done that- but I cant recall! There was a female character in Adam Bakers Outspost that annoyed me. It was a shocker that she wasnt all she seemed and was just selfish and twisted come the end. Interesting Q!
ReplyDeleteThank you for the warm welcome back. It is very nice to be talking books again!
DeleteAs I have been hoping through, I have noticed that there seem to be more female characters that have disappointed us than male characters--have you noticed the same?
I have yet to read Divergent, and have heard mixed reviews. I am sure I will get to it at some point! New follower and thanks for following me too!
ReplyDeleteAs a book--I loved loved loved loved it! But this one character disappointed me.
DeleteI was also so thrilled to see you in Google Reader. I missed you!!!
ReplyDeleteTotally agree on Bridget. She's adorable in book one, but a little annoying in book two. And Al did let me down. And Tris, of course.
I am glad to be back. Now I just have to figure out a routine again so I can make my posts more regular again. :)
DeleteI think it was more that by book two I expected her to learn something. She seemed to be doing a lot of the same things.